Decision ledger

Every load-bearing claim in this repository is ratified in a numbered decision. The ledger is append-only: a decision is superseded by a later one, never edited in place. Superseded entries stay here with their successor linked, because a register that quietly loses its wrong answers cannot be checked.

Id	Decision	Status	Ratified
DEC-0090	Close Phase 02-X: two clauses into two native sources, both with checks the ruling that permitted no check did not need to excuse	●ratified	2026-08-25
DEC-0089	A `blocked` milestone entry names the derivation that would answer whether its blocker still holds, in a fourth native source rather than in the ledger it governs	●ratified	2026-08-25
DEC-0088	`phase:` is required, over a population defined elsewhere and anchored on the date the field began to exist	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0087	Open Phase 02-X on two contract questions, the first phase in this sequence whose deliverable is an amendment rather than a check	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0086	Close Phase 02-W, where a third defect family was named and left without a mechanism on purpose	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0085	Open Phase 02-W on a blocker nobody has priced, and two small items noticed rather than filled	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0084	Close Phase 02-V, where the item dissolved because the phase's first deliverable had already repaired it	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0083	Open Phase 02-V on a practice at the carry ceiling, and the repair its own range cannot demonstrate	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0082	Close Phase 02-U, where the argument killed the mechanism the open had sketched and a prediction died by derivation	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0081	Withdraw petrova-notify-state.yml, because repairing it would deliver a known-wrong phase 29 minutes sooner	●ratified	2026-08-17
DEC-0080	Open Phase 02-U on evidence that history rewriting destroys, with the 02-T close's lost ordering declared rather than repaired	●ratified	2026-08-16
DEC-0079	Close Phase 02-T with its opening question unanswered, one gate undischarged, and the tally's denominator repaired	●ratified	2026-08-16
DEC-0078	A phase may not open without naming the checks CI never runs, and the suite prints the denominator it had been hiding	●ratified	2026-08-16
DEC-0077	Open Phase 02-T on two questions the estate cannot currently answer, with four gates written before their mechanisms	●ratified	2026-08-16
DEC-0076	Close Phase 02-S, with the red pinned, the corpus claim withdrawn rather than repaired, and a contradiction found inside the decision that closed the last phase	●ratified	2026-08-16
DEC-0075	Open Phase 02-S with the red pinned first, because an ambient red is a tolerance that decays	●ratified	2026-08-15
DEC-0074	Close Phase 02-R, with the document winning twice and losing once, and a membership rule replacing a list that was the output of none	●ratified	2026-08-15
DEC-0073	Open Phase 02-R to clear the ledger, with all three carried debts disposed rather than carried	●ratified	2026-08-15
DEC-0072	Close Phase 02-Q, and correct three of the five corrections DEC-0071 made	●ratified	2026-08-15
DEC-0071	Open Phase 02-Q on chain resolvability, correct five numbers DEC-0069 and DEC-0070 got wrong, and move M-04 to planned	●ratified	2026-08-15
DEC-0070	Close Phase 02-P, the estate executed a chain and its own trace format held	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0069	Open Phase 02-P to produce the first real trace, because the critical path turned out to be one environment variable	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0068	Close Phase 02-O, and answer the question, Block H is blocked on an input that has never existed	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0067	A phase opens in its own pull request, because squash-merge is what destroys the evidence	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0066	The organisation count is 40, both 22 and 23 were wrong, and the registry stops claiming to be all of them	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0065	Open Phase 02-O as Block H's entry criteria, because Block H itself is blocked upstream and the deferral is now visible	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0064	Close Phase 02-N, the surfaces observed between ceremonies and the round made able to fail	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0063	Open Phase 02-N to make the surfaces observable between ceremonies, and to name 02-O as Block H	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0062	M2.PETROVA.3 is blocked, not planned, and the carry stops being a decision nobody makes	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0061	REQ-07 governs unit representations, not pages, and names the snapshot it actually generates from	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0060	The apex is grace.parts, the corpus is grace.guide, and grace.pm is not retired by this decision	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0059	Close Phase 02-M, section 5 finished and the budget met on the unit it was written in	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0058	Layout shift is budgeted at 0.01, because zero was never met and costs a reader more than it saves	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0057	Three drafts reached main, and the rule that forbids it was right both times	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0056	Open Phase 02-M to settle section 5.4 on the unit it was written in	●ratified	2026-08-14
DEC-0055	Close Phase 02-L with a red check on the ledger and section 5 not finished	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0054	Open Phase 02-L to weigh the pages and read the copy, closing handbook section 5	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0053	Close Phase 02-K, the cheap answer lost and a milestone was declined inside its own phase	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0052	Decline M2K.2's colour change, and check the class contract instead	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0051	The hairline is decoration, and a control's only edge is not	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0050	Open Phase 02-K to check what surfaces serve rather than what they build, and to settle the hairline	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0049	Close Phase 02-J, the surfaces were accessible and undiscoverable	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0048	Open Phase 02-J to harden the three built surfaces and audit them for accessibility	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0047	Close Phase 02-I, both silent checks now speak and handbook section 4 is complete	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0046	The surface moves, not DESIGN.md, and the two-lane rule now runs the right way	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0045	Open Phase 02-I to repair two checks that could not fire and finish handbook section 4	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0044	Close Phase 02-H, the brand surface has a second reading lane and the leading runs backwards	●ratified	2026-08-13
DEC-0043	PA-3 clause 5 means settlement, and the first rule admitted against a corpus it did not choose	●ratified	2026-08-12
DEC-0042	Open Phase 02-H to give the brand surface a phase and the three carried debts an owner	●ratified	2026-08-12
DEC-0041	Close Phase 02-G, and record that the phase falsified its own opening claim	●ratified	2026-08-12
DEC-0040	Decline M-04, name what replaces it, and record the PaaS direction D-04's brief inherits	●ratified	2026-08-12
DEC-0039	Correct DEC-0034's residual enumeration to twelve, and classify the twelfth	●ratified	2026-08-12
DEC-0038	Amend PA-3 to default-deny, withdraw two repairs that made checks green without work, and bound when a judgment stays a judgment	●ratified	2026-08-12
DEC-0037	Open Phase 02-G to close the gap between PA-3's text and the defect it was written for	●ratified	2026-08-12
DEC-0036	Close Phase 02-F, amend PA-2 for padding, and correct a deployment that never happened	●ratified	2026-08-11
DEC-0035	Work outside a phase is legal below a stated bar, and is enumerated at the next open	●ratified	2026-08-11
DEC-0034	Open Phase 02-F and decide whether work outside a phase is legal	●ratified	2026-08-11
DEC-0033	Block H's tail: H5 and H6 retired, H7 corrected, H8 gated	●ratified	2026-08-11
DEC-0032	Block H's products are build products, and S-2's premise was wrong	●ratified	2026-08-11
DEC-0031	Close Phase 02-D	●ratified	2026-08-10
DEC-0030	Open Phase 02-D and give the grace:// resolver a phase to live in	●ratified	2026-08-10
DEC-0029	Whether grace.guide publishes a real incident in place of a hypothetical one	●ratified	2026-08-10
DEC-0028	grace.pm suspension cleared, and REQ-02 C2 satisfied for the first time	●ratified	2026-08-08
DEC-0027	Em dashes in governance text, frozen and decided by population	●ratified	2026-08-08
DEC-0026	The `parts` path grammar gains a domain-index row	●ratified	2026-08-08
DEC-0025	Two registrars ratified, REQ-02 C1 repealed and the requirement decomposed by clause revises DEC-0016	●ratified	2026-08-08
DEC-0024	Phase 02-B pass 4 close — D-02 resolves, the landing demonstrates its claim	●ratified	2026-08-08
DEC-0023	Open Phase 02-B pass 4 — resolve D-02, and a correction to DEC-0022	●ratified	2026-08-08
DEC-0022	The fingerprint demo lives on grace.guide, the capability lives on grace.parts	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0021	Phase 02-C close — addressing specified, RR-7 closed, RR-8 ratified	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0020	Open Phase 02-C — the grace:// resolver and single-source addressing	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0019	Domain realignment, the two-registrar finding, and grace.pm stays on the tailnet revises DEC-0016	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0018	Phase 02-B pass 3 close, three surfaces crafted and the Casa coupling retired	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0017	Three surface briefs confirmed — content allocation, cutover, REQ-07 amended	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0016	Phase 02-B — close (spec homed, axis ratified, briefs carved out)	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0015	Domain axis — council domains and unit domains are two axes	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0014	GRACE-DOMAIN-SPEC ratified and homed — REQ-01 amended to four domains	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0013	Open Phase 02-B — Surface Split	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0012	Phase 02-A — close (ground truth established, 02-E cancelled, domain axis carved out)	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0011	Hermes naming collision — booked, rename deferred	◐deferred	2026-08-07
DEC-0010	GRACE domain register and trust classes	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0009	Phase 02-E cancelled — cross-repo phase coordination is Mímir's seam revises DEC-0007	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0008	Open Phase 02-A — Ground Truth	●ratified	2026-08-07
DEC-0007	Phase 01 — close (BUNDLE-A verified, M-03 in-progress, four MR-2 carry-overs to Phase 02)	●ratified	2026-05-01
DEC-0006	Phase 01 — open (BUNDLE-A verification close + BUNDLE-E execution kickoff)	●ratified	2026-05-01
DEC-0005	DEC-0005. Design contract ratification (PRODUCT.md, DESIGN.md, drift-watches DW-16/17/18)	●ratified
DEC-0004	PRIMER is the canonical horizontal-scaling mechanism for STRATT	●ratified	2026-04-30
DEC-0003	SPEC-05 execution-trace format is canonical and lives in @stratt/cli (Block I)	●ratified	2026-04-30
DEC-0002	STRATT operates seven councils; further councils require a new ratified decision	●ratified	2026-04-30
DEC-0001	Grace is the routing intelligence between STRATT and Choco	●ratified	2026-04-30
2026-05-06-petrova-rocky-eva-realignment	Adopt PETROVA rocky/eva realignment	◐closed	2026-05-06

This ledger publishes docs/decisions/ only. Verification rounds and design briefs under docs/findings/ are working evidence rather than public commitments, and are not indexed here.